|
Makeover urged for 'North American Union' effort
Heavy criticism of continental integration prompts plan to save
flagging movement
On the verge of next week's
North American summit in
New
Orleans, a
Canadian think tank has suggested
renaming the "North American
Union" to renew progress toward
continental integration in the face of mounting criticism.
A
paper entitled "Saving the North American
Security and Prosperity Partnership",
published last month by the
Fraser
Institute in
Canada, contends
President Bush and Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper have decided
to expend no more political capital in pursuing "the bust" that has
occurred because of the "brand" of the
Security and Prosperity
Partnership of North America or SPP.
The solution, the authors argue,
is a public relations makeover in
which the goals of North American political
and economic integration remain the same
but the names get changed to keep trilateral
arrangements between the U.S.,
Mexico and
Canada on track.
While the paper continues to dismiss critics of the
SPP as "conspiracy theorists," Fraser Institute
political scientist Dr. Alexander Moens and his
co-author Michael Cust, a Fraser Institute intern,
proposes the name "North
American Union," or NAU, be dropped
in favor of a declaration that the three countries now want to create a
"North American Standards and Regulatory Area,"
or NASRA.
Moens and Cust write that
the attacks of SPP critics "are starting to
hurt."
"In the wake of the Montebello Summit (in
Quebec last summer), one Canadian
commentator declared the SPP 'dead' and 'defunct,'" Moens and Cust
noted. "Another stated recently that the SPP has 'collapsed under a heap
of conspiratorial rubbish."
But the authors argue
the SPP is "far from dead."
Acknowledging the SPP has a "low profile"
currently, the Frasier Institute authors stress
that trilateral talks in the bureaucratic working
groups constituted under SPP by the three governments are
continuing on both security and competitiveness policy issues.
"Its critics may have
tarnished the 'SPP brand,'" Moens and Cust concede,
"but the precise areas of its work – to follow where NAFTA left
off and to do so by incorporating post-9/11 security criteria
as well as public safety and quality of life issues (pandemic illnesses
and food safety) – are key Canadian interests."
The Fraser Institute paper also
encourages the SPP working groups to develop
"a better communications strategy,"
so that the public "can begin to understand its benefits."
The authors, however, are
opposed to expanding the list of
SPP advisers to include public interest groups
or the media, preferring to stay
with the closed-door advice offered by the 30
corporations picked by the chambers of commerce in the three countries
to serve as members of the North American Competitiveness
Council, or NACC.
They also concede that Mexico
has been a "drag" on border security talks,
especially since illegal
immigration
into the U.S. has continued, if not
accelerated, under the SPP.
They admit "there is an enormous problem of illegal entry, drug
smuggling, and violent incidents on the Mexican border," while
continuing to argue "there is also a very large legal and
orderly flow of goods between Mexico and the United States."
In 1999, economist Herbert G. Grubel of the Fraser
institute wrote a
paper entitled, "The Case for the Amero,"
presenting the first arguments in print that a North American currency
should be created on the model of the euro in the
European
Union as a replacement for the
U.S. dollar, the Canadian dollar and the Mexican peso.
WND reported
the third SPP summit, held
last August in Montebello, Quebec,
involved a series of closed-door meetings
attended only by the three state heads, the
cabinet members in attendance, the SPP trilateral bureaucrats assigned
to head the 20 working groups established under the SPP and the NACC
business leaders.
Next Monday and Tuesday,
President
Bush will meet in New Orleans
with Mexican President Felipe Calderon and Canadian Prime Minister
Harper.
The White House has
changed the name of the meeting from
the "Fourth SPP Annual Summit"
to simply the "North
American Leaders' Summit."
WND has applied to the White House for press
credential to attend next week's New Orleans meeting.
Editorial Comment:OINK!
OINK! OINK! martha estes
|